Same can be said for several players being undervalued. I recently ran into a Justin Masterson autograph and was shocked to find it available for $3. While he is not going to win the Cy Young Award this season, Masterson has been one of the key players in leading the Cleveland Indians to respectability this season.
2009 Bowman Sterling Justin Masterson Autograph
Three dollars for the autograph of an above-average player is ridiculously cheap. Masterson is out performing pitchers like C.C. Sabathia, but yet his autograph sells for a fraction of the Yankees hurler. Sure, there is the fact that Masterson is stuck playing in Cleveland while Sabathia is toiling in mediocrity under bigger lights in New York, but still there seems to be little reasoning behind the price some collectors pay for the signatures of certain players. Masterson does have a pretty extensive line of autographs and signed frequently as a younger player including several on-card signatures.