Hall of Famers can be hundreds, if not thousands of dollars. Occasionally you can find a Cracker Jack card for around $50, but not very often. Inexpensive usually means that there are condition issues that go above and beyond.
Not my card, but a good example of a Cracker Jack card with a few flaws.
So, for years I have set aside my dream of owning a Cracker Jack card from yesteryear in favor of just owning a few nice ones from the Topps rehash from 2004 and 2005. Still pretty nice players in there.
My two favorite Cracker Jack cards are.......
My Yadier Molina rookie card out of the 2004 set.
I also have a Miguel Cabrera autograph. He's looks like he's in middle school in this picture.
Recently one of the unaffordable Cracker Jack cards that is on my short list came available. It's of George Whitted, or Possum Whitted, who is a Durham, North Carolina native. I have been trying to find a few of his cards over the past few months. I have been successful.
He was on the Phillies at the time his Cracker Jack card was made, but he also played for the Cardinals and for the Durham Bulls. He also managed the Bulls. There has been a Buy It Now copy of this card on Ebay for awhile, but at $250 I have been passing month after month.
It's not the cleanest copy, but I picked it up on the low end of the price spectrum for a Cracker Jack card. The $250 card, but on major clearance. I am really happy to add this to my Durham Bulls/Cardinals collection. It's already high on my list, and it's not been here for long.
It's in a protective case, so it's not the best scan.
There are two main flaws with the card. First, there is chipping along with the edges near the top left corner. The mark on the side almost looks like it could be from a thumbtack. The card is also discolored along the bottom border. I am not quite sure why it is discolored, I am a little scared to take it out of the case at this point.
Here is the back. I had originally tried to scan the back, but it did not turn out very well. I flipped the photo since the backs are upside on Cracker Jack cards.
I like the bio on the back of this card, which mentions that he is from Durham and that he was on the Cardinals. There is also mention of him playing in Wadesboro, which is near Charlotte, but there is nothing on his Baseball Reference page about him being on that team. In fact, when you try to find information about baseball in Wadesboro the only thing that pops up is information about an Expos Minor Leaguer from the early 2000s who was from that town.
Not my card, but Antonio Garris owns the search for Wadesboro and baseball.
Overall, it feels good to own a Cracker Jack card that is more than a century old. Even better that it is a player who appeared for my favorite Major and Minor League teams. Quite a prize.
