I decided that I did not want to miss out on having the card, and it's not like Topps really did anything to help resolve the situation, so I went ahead and traded for another copy of the card. This time the card came in a nice bubble mailer and was in good condition.
The scan is a little bit crooked, not my best day, but the card also does not have a big crease in it. After completing the trade it has become clear to me that the best way to pick up these cards is to let other people buy them and pick them up on the secondary market. Trade partners and sellers on sites like Ebay want to maintain their reputation, they know how to package cards, and if something were to go wrong I probably won't be ignored.
Besides trading for the Aledmys rookie card I also picked up a nice Wil Myers card.....
This is from this year's Topps Chrome set. I have picked up some cards from that set, but have yet to post them on here. This is an insert set featuring different Rookie of the Year winners. Myers is one of two former Durham Bulls players in the set along with Longoria. There are also autographed versions of these cards, but the seem like they might be a little pricy.